How do we fix the problems at the JUTC ?

Firstly we cannot fix a problem if we do not understand the nature of the problem.

Secondly, we cannot fix the problem, if we employ persons who do not have the requisite management and technical skills in mass transit management.

Thirdly we can never solve the problem by bring in more and more comrades to replace those who have left, because the thinking is the same, which means the problems will only continue or get worse.

Its time like this I wish I were a comrade, who with a radically different approach, would move to really solve the JUTC problem. 🙂

I would do the following :

  1. Employ a group of high school students  and University to go to the Gemba.
  2. Have the Phillip Paulwell provide them with tablets to be used for data collection.
  3. These folks will be stationed at the various depot’s in Kingston and Spanishtown used by the JUTC. They would also be placed at major transport center ie HWT, Downtown, Constant Spring etc as well as selected bus stops along every route serviced by the JUTC.
  4. Some would be placed on buses along every route travel by JUTC solely for data collection.

 

Data to be collected

  1. Average number of  paying passenger per bus on all routes.
  2. Category of paying passing ie students, elderly or regular.
  3. Average number of persons embarking and disembarking along the various routes.
  4. Average number of passengers during peak periods
  5. Category of paying passengers during peak periods
  6. Average number of passenger during off peak hrs.
  7. Category of paying passengers during off peak hrs
  8. Average wait time per bus stop.
  9. Average wait period at major bus centers (idle time)
  10. Run time of engine during ideal periods at bus stop.
  11. Average number of buses on various routes during peak periods
  12. Average number of buses on various routes during off peak periods.
  13. Average number of passenger who complete the entire journey ie from terminus to terminus.
  14. Average length of ride per passenger ie what distance does the average passenger travels.

Given what I have already seen JUTC can look at the following

  1. Get fleet of smaller buses like the Toyota Coasters or even  Toyota Hiace
  2. Run large buses during peak periods and where passenger loads are such that the bus will run at no less than 85% capacity.
  3. Run smaller buses on low volume routes and during peak periods on routes where it’s not economically viable to run the larger buses.
  4. Stop  running on some routes where the load factors are so low that you can never break even or make a profit.
  5. Divest these routes to smaller operates who in turn pay JUTC a fee to run on these routes.

 

I gave this JUTC bus situation 15 minutes of thought before writing this post and I am sure if I spent a couple hrs thinking about it some more I surely could come up with some better ideas on how to deal with the bus company financial problems.

 

Next I will look at the maintenance operations and how to deal with that, but I got to run now… Will try to complete that before the end of this week.

Food for thought. Darn I probably should not use the word food. 

Lol

 

PS : Use the JEEP money to pay them.

 

12 Responses

  1. Please do not share the above the Colin Campbell, he may steal my ideas and pass them off as his own and I would get no credit. 🙂

    Can anyone recall a politicians saying something along those lines in 2011 ?

    It just goes to show who is really serious about moving the country forward vs striving to achieve focused personal goals, which are not necessarily in line with what is required to solve our problems.

    Mi nah call nuh name but a sure if you all look back you would know to whom this commented is being directed.

  2. Another disaster is occurring at NSWMA. In the Ocho Rios depot, i have counted at least seven units down, most if not all without tires. The Crane truck has been stripped of all tires and the few collecting garbage could not pass a fitness test. A few years ago i offered to volunteer my Transportation Management knowledge and skills, tried and proven Internationally, but the offer was not taken up. What i met were people given jobs thru politics and who had no clue of what was required of them. As a matter of fact, while talking to the mechanic then, i overheard a conversation with a Board member enquiring about Truck tyres. You can read whatever you want into that. Lol.

  3. […] at Common Sense Jamaica, Jay has two posts up on fixing our government bus company, the Jamaican Urban Transit Company. However, looking […]

  4. One blogger has suggested that what is here is a technical solution to a political problem and sadly I think he is correct.

  5. interesting post… im a transport engineer who still (in a sense) works with the govt. some of those very ideas have been touted to solve the problems but let me shed a little light on them for you
    1. Use smaller buses. Nice theory and it may work on some routes but hurdle number 1. You need to buy more buses which in turn means more drivers, more fuel, more maintenance. If you buy small buses what do you do with the big ones? If you plan to continue driving them you need drivers etc. If you park them then you have a lost investment.
    2.Run a peaking service – currently being done
    3. Same as 1
    4. and 5. That is currently being done. But remember the Govt has an obligation of sorts to provide transportation even if it is at a loss.

  6. When any entity suffers major losses through pilfering then its fate is sealed. The loss of Diesel and Tyres which are a significant part of the operational cost is mind boggling. Those problems can easily be fixed.

    • I agree with the point about not having technical people. public transport operations is a specialised engineering field that we seem to think lay people can do – they end up putting both labourites and comrades, neither party has a monopoly on the issue. one of the huge problems is we cant pay the engineers and transport planners. Govt has historically not paid technical people their worth and as a result we lose those people to foreign markets.

      i think they have been doing a good job on reducing pilferage of diesel. tyres were never a problem

      • You got to be dreaming!! In the “real world”, JUTC tyres are on numerous Tractor Trailers all over the Island branded and all.

        • dont forget that there are two companies name JUTC. the Jamaica Urban Transport Company ie the bus company and the Jamaica Utimate Tyre Company – that was set up to sell tires to the bus company. (dont ask me why). The tyre company also sells tires in the open market. perhaps tyres were stolen in the past..but its not a problem that i know of. Diesel …well thats a whole different story.

  7. Ultimate has no reason to brand their tyres! The leakage is real. Still not sure if it has been cauterized.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: